Buying an LLC interest versus contributing cash to become a second member

· 3 min read

Start with a factual distinction when a second owner joins a disregarded domestic LLC. Did the newcomer pay the current owner for part of the LLC, or contribute capital to the business for an interest? Revenue Ruling 99-5 analyzes both fact patterns. In each, the entity becomes a partnership under the ruling's assumptions, but the federal transactions leading to that classification differ.

Follow the money and the assets

In the ruling's purchase example, the newcomer pays the existing owner. Federal income-tax analysis treats that person as acquiring an undivided interest in the LLC's assets, followed by contributions to the partnership. In the contribution example, cash goes into the entity. The former sole owner and the new member are treated as making contributions to the new partnership. The accounting work needed for cost, basis and effective dates depends on these facts and any facts outside the ruling.

Keep the contract, transfer confirmation, contribution records and property list together. Trace consideration to an actual recipient. If a single agreement contains a payment to the seller, new cash for business operations, and assumption of liabilities, flag each element separately. A transaction with mixed consideration or a preexisting corporate election needs its own analysis.

Worked comparison

A founder and a newcomer agree that the newcomer will hold a 40 percent interest. In one draft, the newcomer pays the founder personally. In a second draft, the same amount goes into a business account for working capital. The member register looks similar at the end of the day. A useful packet shows the different movement of funds and the assets and liabilities at the admission date. The accountant uses that evidence to evaluate the treatment of the closing and opening positions.

Build a reporting handoff

  • Keep the signed admission or purchase instrument and its effective date.
  • Obtain the account statements that show who received the purchase price or contribution.
  • List material assets with book values, historical tax basis, and supporting records where available.
  • Identify liabilities the parties agreed to transfer or assume.
  • Give the preparer the LLC's classification evidence and record where pre-change activity was reported.

Ask the preparer to check the new partnership reporting requirements and the relevant taxpayer identifier for the operation after the change. The state may continue to recognize the same LLC throughout, while the ownership and classification timeline for federal filing has two segments. Keep the state and federal records alongside each other so the effective dates can be reconciled. Avoid promising a tax-free result solely from calling a transfer a contribution.

Official sources

  1. IRS Bulletin 1999-6, Revenue Rulings 99-5 and 99-6
  2. Treasury Regulation 26 CFR §301.7701-3
  3. IRS overview of LLC classification