Using Form 1040-ES (NR) to Estimate a Nonresident Withholding Shortfall

· 3 min read

A nonresident can have U.S. income from which no federal income tax is withheld, or it can be withheld at an amount below the expected tax. IRS guidance identifies Form 1040-ES (NR) as the package for a nonresident alien to figure and pay estimated tax. The worksheet is a forward-looking calculation. Start with the items expected in the relevant year, then decide whether a prior-year return is available for a valid comparison.

Separate projected tax and projected payments

Use a running record of expected items of taxable income, deductions or other adjustments relevant to the filing, and taxes already expected to be withheld. If a payer begins withholding late in the year or income varies by project, capture the expected change rather than multiplying one deposit by twelve. Compare tax on the projected income with the withholding and relevant refundable credits used in the estimated-tax test.

Publication 519's 2026 discussion describes a general obligation where expected tax remaining reaches at least $1,000 and withholding plus certain refundable credits are below the smaller of two figures. These are generally 90 percent of the current year's expected tax and 100 percent of the tax shown on a qualifying prior-year return. The prior-year comparison depends on the earlier return covering all 12 months, and the publication describes circumstances in which a higher prior-year percentage applies. Keep those facts in the calculation rather than copying the prior-year amount as a universal threshold.

Review a simple projected-income example

Assume the taxpayer estimates $6,000 in total current-year tax, expects $2,000 in withholding and has no relevant refundable credits. Suppose the prior full-year return showed $4,800 in tax and no higher-percentage rule applies. The 90-percent current comparison is $5,400. The lower comparison amount is $4,800. Two thousand dollars in withholding is below that comparison and the projected tax remaining is $4,000. The example identifies why estimated payments need review under the 2026 guidance. It does not determine installment amounts, which should come from the applicable worksheet.

If the taxpayer did not file the previous year's return, Publication 519 says the prior-year item does not apply. If income, deductions or credits changed materially, revisit the estimate and use the correct year's rate schedule. This is particularly important after a residency or activity change because the prior-year form does not necessarily predict the new year's obligations.

Connect the calculation to the payment record

Publication 519 discusses the timing of the first payment by reference to the previous year's Form 1040-NR filing due date, with details that depend on whether the filer has wages subject to the applicable withholding rules. Check the current Form 1040-ES (NR) payment schedule and worksheet before relying on a general quarterly calendar. Keep payment dates and amounts alongside the worksheet.

At return preparation, reconcile actual estimated payments to the account records and list them separately from federal tax withheld by payers. Retain the prior-year form if it was used in the comparison and preserve each revised estimate. That record shows why an earlier installment estimate may differ from the final return due when the year's income did not follow the original projection.

Official sources

  1. About Form 1040-ES (NR), U.S. Estimated Tax for Nonresident Alien Individuals
  2. 2025 Publication 519