Building a Form 8840 File When Your Foreign Tax Home Changed Countries
· 3 min read
A person who meets the substantial presence test but spent fewer than 183 days in the United States this year may qualify for the closer-connection exception. A midyear move between foreign countries makes the supporting record more demanding. The question is whether the tax home and contacts during the year meet the two-country conditions Publication 519 describes. A single foreign mailing address is too little information to answer it.
Check the entry conditions before assembling evidence
Run the U.S. substantial presence calculation first. The closer-connection rule discussed here may apply when the filer meets that test but was present in the United States fewer than 183 days in the current year. Also check whether the person applied, took steps to change to permanent resident status, or had an adjustment application pending during the year. Publication 519 identifies circumstances in which those actions prevent the claim.
Separate a tax home from merely keeping a house or receiving correspondence in a country. The publication describes the tax home in terms of the area of the regular or principal work location, with different rules for someone who does not have such a workplace. For a person whose work dictates an indefinite location, examine the employment or business arrangements that apply to each period.
Chart the two foreign-country periods
The publication allows a closer connection to two foreign countries in limited circumstances. The taxpayer must maintain a tax home in the first country at the beginning of the year, change it to a second foreign country, and keep it in the second country for the remainder of the year. In each period, the closer connection must be to the corresponding foreign country rather than to the United States. The foreign resident-taxation condition also must be met, whether through residence taxation in one country for the whole year or in both countries for their respective periods.
For example, a consultant with a settled workplace in Country A moves it to Country B in August. Add the move date and employment records to the worksheet. Then examine the tax residence rules that applied and the personal and business connections supporting each period. A short visit to another country in the middle of the move does not automatically change the tax home, while a gap or an actual third tax home calls for more analysis.
Connect records to the statements on the form
Publication 519 identifies possible factors such as the permanent home, family, belongings, driver license, business activities, voting and the residence stated on official documents. Use records connected to the dates being reviewed. A foreign residence document valid at year-end may say little about the first half of the year. An explanation of how ties moved can be more useful than a collection of recent documents that never mentions the earlier country.
Attach completed Form 8840 to the income tax return to make a closer-connection claim. If no return is required, follow the separate submission instructions. The publication ties timing to the Form 1040-NR due date and describes consequences of an untimely filing. Save the completed form, the residency calculation, the work-location timeline and the evidence behind each country period so the proposed filing position can be reviewed against the same facts.