Making a Section 871(d) Election With More Than One U.S. Rental Property

· 3 min read

A nonresident alien with income from two U.S. rentals may be tempted to compare gross withholding with expenses property by property and elect only for the more expensive building. The IRS description of the section 871(d) election addresses all covered U.S. real property held for the production of income and interests in such property. Prepare an inventory of the taxpayer's interests before deciding whether and how to make the election.

Establish the existing treatment for the property income

The IRS describes a general 30-percent rate, or a lower applicable treaty rate, when a nonresident alien's U.S. real property income is not effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business. The election applies to qualifying income that is not already connected with the taxpayer's U.S. trade or business. After a timely valid election the taxpayer can claim deductions attributable to covered property income, and the net income is taxed at graduated rates. The result therefore depends on both income and allowable deductions.

For example, suppose an owner has two U.S. rentals, one with repairs and a lower profit and another with stable income and few expenses. Include both in evaluating the proposed election. Treating the election as a choice for individual monthly deposits would omit a property the IRS expects to be addressed. The election does not by itself treat an otherwise nonbusiness taxpayer as conducting a U.S. trade or business during the year.

Build a complete statement

The IRS guidance describes attaching a statement to Form 1040-NR, or to the applicable amended return for the year of election. The statement identifies the election and addresses whether the choice is made under section 871(d) or a treaty. Prepare a list of relevant properties or interests, locations, the extent of direct or beneficial ownership, major improvements, ownership dates and income. Also record earlier election or revocation years where applicable. A purchase statement, lease, rental ledger and payment records can help reconcile the inventory.

On the 2025 Form 1040-NR, Schedule OI item M distinguishes the first year of the election from a previous election still in effect. Treat the checkbox as part of the filing rather than as a replacement for the required initial statement. Confirm the instructions for the actual return year.

Plan for the payer and later-year filings

The IRS guidance calls for giving a Form W-8ECI to the withholding agent or payer in the first election year and again when required. Track which agent has a current valid form. Keep the copy given to the payer separate from the statement attached to the tax return, because they serve different functions.

The guidance says the owner must file Form 1040-NR for the first election year and every subsequent year while the election remains in effect. It describes potential limitations on deductions and some credits after untimely filing without a waiver, and separate rules for revocation. Carry the election history into the annual file so subsequent preparers can identify a continuing election and account for any properties purchased or sold since the initial statement.

Official sources

  1. Nonresident aliens – Real property located in the U.S.
  2. 2025 Schedule OI (Form 1040-NR)