Which Transit and Cross-Border Commuting Days Count Toward U.S. Tax Residency?

· 3 min read

A short stay in the United States can be a countable day for the substantial presence test. There are separate exclusions for qualifying transit and regular commuting from Canada or Mexico. The fact that both situations can involve stretches of less than 24 hours can make them look interchangeable. A travel connection turns on the endpoints and purpose of the itinerary. Commuting turns on where the person lives, whether each trip qualifies, and the pattern of workdays during the working period.

Test the whole transit itinerary

Publication 519 excludes qualifying U.S. presence of less than 24 hours when traveling between two places outside the United States. The activity in the United States must be substantially related to completing the trip to the foreign destination. Changing planes can satisfy that description, including travel between U.S. airports for the connection. An independent business meeting cuts against that description even when it takes place inside the airport.

For example, consider two travelers taking an overnight connection from one foreign city to another. Each remains in the United States less than 24 hours. The first spends the wait transferring between airports for the next flight. The second schedules a buyer meeting before taking the same onward flight. The trip length is identical. The purpose of the intervening activity yields a different result under the transit rule. A person whose trip starts or ends in the United States also lacks the two foreign endpoints required by this particular exclusion.

Measure the commuter pattern

A Canada or Mexico resident can disregard qualifying days of commuting to work in the United States if the person regularly commutes. Publication 519 describes a commute as traveling to work and returning to the residence within a 24-hour period. The person must commute to U.S. work on more than 75 percent of workdays during the working period.

Start the working period on the first day physically present in the United States to work and end it on the last such day in the current year as described in the publication. The guidance also discusses special timing for seasonal or cyclical work. The denominator includes the days worked in the United States, Canada or Mexico during the relevant period. It does not simply equal the number of U.S. border crossings.

Suppose a qualifying working period contains 80 workdays. Sixty U.S. commute days are exactly 75 percent and therefore do not meet a requirement that is greater than 75 percent. Sixty-one such days out of 80 exceed the threshold. Even in the second example, an unrelated U.S. vacation day should be evaluated as its own day.

Keep two kinds of travel evidence

For transit, retain the departure point, the onward destination, timing and the reason for any intervening stop. For commuting, reconcile border dates with workdays, work locations and return-home timing. If a business trip changes a regular commute or a holiday changes the working calendar, write that exception beside the dates it affects.

Then update the day count used for the substantial presence test. Retain the underlying travel ledger even when a particular exclusion leaves the final residency result unchanged. It lets the filer explain which rule was applied on each date instead of trying to reconstruct the reason from a crossing record alone.

Official sources

  1. 2025 Publication 519