Penalty after following incorrect written IRS advice: which records show reliance?

· 2 min read

The IRS describes a statutory basis for penalty relief when a taxpayer received incorrect written IRS advice in response to their written request and relied on it. The file should show which question was asked, what the IRS said and how the answer led to the charge identified in the notice. Start by assembling those records in the order they occurred.

Gather the request, the answer and the tax action

Find your written question and the IRS reply. Identify the date and issue covered on both. Then locate the return, payment or other record showing your action. If the facts in your request changed before you acted, explain those differences. The IRS asks for a copy of the advice, an explanation of reliance and the notice identifying the resulting charge.

Document What it should help show
Your original written request The question and circumstances presented to the IRS
The IRS written advice The answer you received before taking the relevant action
Evidence of reliance What action followed the advice and why
Penalty notice or examination record Which charge resulted from the issue

Explain the link in your response

Follow the instructions on the penalty notice. State the specific penalty and period you want the IRS to reconsider. Connect the written advice with the action you took. The IRS says some requests may be handled over the phone. When relief cannot be approved that way, its guidance describes a written request using Form 843. The route depends on the notice and the penalty involved.

Example: Advice exists but the question is missing

A taxpayer has a letter that appears to describe how to handle a particular tax item. The notice now charges a penalty connected with that item. Before filing a request, the taxpayer retrieves the original written inquiry and the records of the action taken after the reply. These documents let the IRS compare the question, the advice and the resulting charge instead of seeing the advisory letter in isolation.

Official sources

  1. Penalty relief due to statutory exception
  2. Penalty relief