Form 843 for nonresident payroll taxes withheld in error: What if your employer only repaid part?

· 3 min read

If Social Security or Medicare tax was withheld from pay that was exempt from those taxes, Publication 519 tells the employee to request a refund from the employer first. If the employer cannot or does not refund the full amount, use Form 843 for the remaining claim and document the reimbursement the employer actually made. Check eligibility for the relevant period before calculating a refund. Visa status alone does not establish every condition.

Establish the exempt employment period

Review the dates, immigration documentation and activities tied to the employment. If an exemption applies for only part of the year, preserve pay statements showing the tax withheld during the exempt period. A Form W-2 can show the annual totals without allocating those amounts to each part of the year. Match the pay statements to the relevant work and dates.

Evidence Role in the claim
Form W-2 and pay statements Show the withholding and, where needed, the amount tied to the exempt period.
Visa, I-94 or other arrival/departure record Establish the applicant’s relevant immigration and presence facts.
Additional status or work authorization documents Check DS-2019 for J-1, complete I-20 for F-1 or M-1, and I-766 for optional practical training, as applicable.
Employer statement or alternative Show reimbursement and credit or refund amounts claimed or authorized, including why the employer statement is unavailable if necessary.

Recover only the part the employer did not refund

Suppose a nonresident determines that 450 dollars of regular Social Security and Medicare tax was withheld in error, and the employer repays 300 dollars. The reconciliation identifies the remaining 150 dollars before evaluating the IRS claim. Ask the employer to state the reimbursement and any credit or refund claimed or authorized. If the statement is unavailable, use the alternative statement or Form 8316 procedure described in Publication 519 and explain the missing documentation.

Avoid using unrelated withholdings to inflate the claim. Additional Medicare Tax has different instructions. Publication 519 directs filers to Form 8959 for a credit when the additional tax was withheld in error, rather than using Form 843 for it.

Preserve the payroll and refund timeline

Keep the Form W-2, pay statements, exempt-period records, employer requests and actual refund evidence together. Date the reconciliation so the preparer can tell whether a later reimbursement changed the remaining balance. Review the applicable filing instructions before submitting the claim.

Official sources

  1. 2025 Publication 519
  2. Instructions for Form 1040-NR (2025)