A payroll tax deposit was short: test the amount and the makeup deadline
· 3 min read
Federal employment tax deposits generally need to cover the full liability by the due date. Publication 15 describes an accuracy rule that can prevent a penalty for certain small shortfalls when two conditions are met. First, the difference must be no more than the greater of $100 or 2 percent of the tax that should have been deposited. Second, the employer must pay or deposit the difference by the applicable makeup date. Check the amount and timing separately before treating the deposit as corrected.
Calculate the gap from what was required
Pull the original payroll liability, the due date and the proof of deposit. Verify that the liability and the amount actually deposited belong to the same return period. Subtract what was deposited from what was due. Then calculate 2 percent of the amount otherwise required to be deposited and compare it with $100. For example, if $7,000 was due, the comparison is $140 versus $100. A $120 shortfall satisfies this part of the accuracy rule, assuming the underlying calculation and deposit are correct. A $150 shortfall in the same case does not. Keep the amounts and the deposit reference together. This calculation uses the amount originally required for the deposit, not the remaining gap. Check the payroll workpaper for a late correction to the amount that was supposed to be paid. A notice may show an assessed amount while a payroll report shows total liability. Identify which figure is being used at each step rather than combining entries from different periods.
Choose the applicable makeup date
Publication 15 says a monthly schedule depositor can deposit the difference or pay it with the return by the due date of the return for the period in which the shortfall occurred. It specifically describes paying the shortfall with the return even if it is $2,500 or more. For a semiweekly schedule depositor, the date is the earlier of the first Wednesday or Friday on or after the fifteenth of the following month and the due date for the return. Calculate both dates for the semiweekly case, then select the earlier one. Verify which return period applies before relying on the later date.
Preserve the original and makeup transactions
Do not overwrite the original deposit proof with the later one. Record why the gap occurred, how its size was calculated and the effective date of the makeup payment. Match the confirmations to the same obligation and check the date and amount. If the gap was too large or the makeup date already passed, review the applicable deposit penalty guidance and any actual IRS notice. The two-part rule calls for both the size and the correction timing to qualify.
If a semiweekly depositor has a May shortfall, start with June 15 and identify the first Wednesday or Friday on or after that date. Compare it with the return deadline for the period of that deposit and use whichever comes first. The original confirmation identifies the period to use in that comparison.