Section 351 control when founders transfer property for voting and nonvoting stock
· 2 min read
When founders exchange property for corporate stock, the usual Section 351 nonrecognition analysis considers control immediately after the exchange. IRS Publication 542 describes two separate ownership measures: at least 80% of the combined voting power and at least 80% of the outstanding shares of each class of nonvoting stock.
Identify the transaction and the transferors before calculating control
List the people or entities contributing property and the stock each one receives. Document the legal corporation issuing the stock. The general rule can apply to a group transferring property together, whether the corporation is new or already operating. Publication 542 describes an exchange for the corporation's stock other than nonqualified preferred stock, subject to its stated exceptions. Review the complete agreements before assuming every interest issued at closing counts the same way.
Collect the shareholder register immediately after the exchange, the rights of each class, and any closing steps that affect the ownership figures. A term sheet may state an economic percentage across classes without showing the two measurements needed here.
| Control measure | What to calculate | Where to verify |
|---|---|---|
| Combined voting power | Transferors' share of the vote across all voting classes | Charter and post-exchange register |
| Each nonvoting class | Transferors' share of the outstanding shares in that class | Class-by-class capitalization |
| Measurement time | Ownership immediately after the exchange | Closing and issuance records |
Check a case that passes only one measure
Assume the property transferors hold 90% of combined voting power immediately after the exchange, but only 70 of 100 outstanding shares of one nonvoting class. They satisfy the voting figure and fail the nonvoting figure on those facts. If they hold 80 shares of that class instead, both numerical thresholds are met, assuming the ownership and class records support the calculation. That does not resolve other requirements.
Preserve the reporting evidence
Publication 542 explains that the corporation and anyone involved in a nontaxable property-for-stock exchange must attach to their income tax returns for the exchange year the statement of relevant facts required by Treasury Regulations section 1.351-3. Assemble a closing file that identifies the property and stock, dates, accepted values and basis records, and control workpaper. Check the publication's exceptions, including specified investment company and debt situations, before treating control as sufficient to conclude that the transaction qualifies.