Can you revoke a section 871(d) rental-income election after the amendment period?

· 3 min read

A nonresident who elected under section 871(d) to treat U.S. real property income as effectively connected should identify the original election year before trying to revoke the choice. Publication 519 describes a limited route to revocation through amended returns without prior IRS approval. Once the time window closes for the original election year, the taxpayer cannot revoke for that year and needs IRS approval to revoke for a later year.

Locate the filing and payment records for the election year

Find the initial election statement and the annual return it accompanied. Then identify when the original return was filed and when the tax was paid. Publication 519 explains the time restriction for the Form 1040-X route as three years from filing the return or two years from paying the tax, whichever is later. Determine the dates using evidence rather than estimating from the return’s printed year.

Decision Record that supports it
Identify the original election year First election statement and corresponding return.
Check the amendment route Compare filing-date and payment-date windows using documentary evidence.
Handle affected returns When using the route without IRS approval, review Form 1040-X for the election year and later affected years.
Assess a later revocation after expiration Consult the IRS approval process under the cited regulation.

Understand what happens after the window closes

Suppose an owner’s original filing date gives a three-year window and a later tax payment gives a two-year window that ends after it. The owner identifies the later date for the described amendment route. If preparing the revocation only after that later date passes, the owner cannot use the route to revoke the original year. They review the procedure for approval if seeking revocation for a later year. Reporting the rent differently on one later return would not by itself document a valid revocation.

Keep annual filings and payer records aligned with the election status

The election stays in effect until revoked. Track the status before completing Schedule OI or notifying a withholding agent. A sale of one property or a change in property managers does not document whether the tax election was revoked. The IRS guidance requires Form 1040-NR for each year the election remains in effect. Review which amended returns and withholding certificates need updating once the effective change is confirmed.

Store the initial statement, original and amended returns, filing and payment evidence, and any approval together. A later preparer should be able to identify when the election started, which revocation route was used, and the first year to which the change applies.

Official sources

  1. 2025 Publication 519
  2. Nonresident aliens – Real property located in the U.S.