Why a single-member LLC can have two EINs in old payroll records
· 3 min read
Two EINs in the historical payroll records of a single-member LLC can reflect a federal employment tax transition. For tax periods beginning on or after January 1, 2009, a single-member LLC disregarded for federal income tax purposes is generally treated as a separate taxpayer for employment taxes and reports them under the LLC's own name and EIN. For older periods, the IRS manual describes circumstances in which an EIN was assigned to the owner and a separate one to the LLC. Start by identifying the tax period and the entity each number belongs to.
Why the transition matters
For earlier periods, IRS Notice 99-6 permitted the LLC's employment taxes to be calculated, reported and paid under either the LLC's name and EIN or the owner's name and EIN. The IRS manual says this notice became obsolete for tax periods beginning on or after January 1, 2009. The LLC generally continues to be disregarded for federal income tax purposes. Payroll records and income-tax records can therefore use different identifiers for a valid reason.
| Record being reviewed | Identifier to check |
|---|---|
| Payroll record for a period ending before January 1, 2009 | Review the actual filing and identify whether it used the owner or LLC under the old approach |
| Payroll record for a period beginning on or after January 1, 2009 | Verify the LLC's name and EIN for federal employment tax |
| Income-tax identification for a disregarded LLC | Check the owner's identifier under the applicable income-tax instructions |
Example: Payroll files from 2008 and 2010
An owner finds that the 2008 payroll archive uses a number tied to the owner, while the 2010 returns show the LLC's legal name and a different number. The owner retrieves the assignment records for both numbers and labels each by entity. The next review distinguishes the historical record under the prior approach from the LLC's own payroll filing after the transition. Simply replacing the older identifier across all saved records would erase that distinction.
Verify the account before changing a record
Sort the underlying payroll forms and assignment documents by entity and reporting period before making a correction. If the review concerns payroll now, check the current LLC name and identify its own EIN. If the review concerns an archived filing, preserve the original and verify the exact period under review. Finding a second number in legacy paperwork is a reason to reconcile the records before submitting any new EIN application.